Hi
I have had the same problem. However in my case I want to be able to "spoof" the list. I send HTML newsletters to the list from FrontPage -> Outlook -> Hotmail -> mailist@my_domain. In other words I send from a hotmail address with a return/reply to set to the only allowed address!
This information mismatch may also be in the X-Sender information by the way! Have a look at the spammers header and they may have the X-Sender set to the real domain. It is probably a quick and dirty to redirect at that point although I think many people use this method to send mail to a list!!
In my case it is a newsletter so after it happened the first time it was easier to shut the list down after posting the newsletter than to hack the rcfiles for check/filter for a match between hotmail/reply to address.
By the way I have modified my procfiles to remove all the X-Sender information which got me into a lot of strife with Hotmail recently. Because the X-Sender was still in the header and out of 35,000 emails I had a few "not happy Jon's" hotmail killed off my Premium account for a while!
Email me if you want the modified file which allows you to post to the list from a non subscribed address but remove where the post came from. Sort of allows people to do exactly what you are complaining about but it is useful sometimes :-)
jon
Prof Jon Jenkins MLC Parliament House Macquarie Street Sydney NSW 2000 Sydney Office Ph/Fax 02-9230-2752/2205 Nth Coast Office Ph/Fax 02-6676-2947/1543 Mob 0429178817 jon@trac.org.au www.trac.org.au
-----Original Message----- From: smartlist-bounces@lists.RWTH-Aachen.DE [mailto:smartlist-bounces@lists.RWTH-Aachen.DE] On Behalf Of Charlie Summers Sent: Saturday, 3 June 2006 1:10 AM To: Harshal; SmartList Subject: Re:Spam with subscriber's 'from' address
At 10:25 AM -0400 6/2/06, Harshal is rumored to have typed:
Any suggestions on how to handle this problem?
Filter out that user's address (explaining to him the problem, of course) into your private mailbox*; if it continues with different subscribed addresses, it's likely a manual spam by an existing subscriber. Your only option there is to 1) moderate the list, and 2) report every spam to the upstreams until it becomes too much of a hassle for the spammer to continue.
Charlie
- There are a bazillion ways of writing procmail recipies to
allow the "real" user to post while the clone cannot, but it assumes a familiarity with email header fields and procmail. In my case, for example, you could check for my address _and_ my mail server in the header fields; if mail with my address isn't delivered by 69.93.98.146, redirect away from the list to your private mailbox.
Smartlist mailing list Smartlist@lists.RWTH-Aachen.DE http://MailMan.RWTH-Aachen.DE/mailman/listinfo/smartlist